May 31 2009
Immigration: Two Pronged Approach
Again, this story is a little old, but worth discussing nonetheless. Basically, data shows that with the recession, migration from Mexico to the U.S. has fallen.
It attributes this to both increased enforcement along the border and the lack of jobs due to the economic downturn.
Now, let’s use a common phrase to explain this. Basically, it’s a twist on the idea of the carrot and the stick. Instead of working together, though, they compete. We can increase the “stick,” that is the threat of deportation or punishment, but obviously, for some, the draw of the carrot, a good job and better life, still manages to trump the stick.
Short of continuing the recession, however, what can we do to ensure there are not enough jobs to draw illegal immigrants over the border? And how can we ensure that there are still enough jobs to draw the legal migrants who contribute so much to our economy?
The answer is simple. Crack down not only on illegal immigrants, but also those that employ them.
Moreover, we now have a great opportunity to make real change on the immigration issue. I know that between the wars and the economy, people think we need to focus on other issues.
On the other hand, I’m sure it’s not just Mexico that has slowed the flow of migration. And we know travel is way down. Therefor, if we change immigration policies now, we will disrupt the flow of legal migration and travel less than at “busier times.” Moreover, we have time to troubleshoot and adjust new laws, training, and technology while the flow of both tourists and migrants over our borders is slow. Remember after 9/11? Showing up 4-6 hours before your flight?
So my plea to our elected officials is to make real changes to our immigration system, and do it quickl